Ticket Change Details
Overview

Artifact ID: a7a9eea528610115e6dd4a1524b7c37a7aca41713b614f2f50f085de3ebe3c20
Ticket: e01f02a12180ac37cdb96ec16d0e03f89033cd77
Segfault under wish at first tls::import, not under tclsh
User & Date: anonymous 2020-09-02 06:40:21
Changes

  1. Change icomment to:

    Huh, that was easier to solve than I thought.

    First, the easiest way of demonstrating that the symbol bindings are wrong is to set the environment variable DYLD_PRINT_BINDINGS. With that, and the default linker flags for shared-tcltls.dylib, we get (in the vicinity of DH_new):

    dyld: lazy forcedbind: tcltls.dylib:0x100742118 = libcrypto.0.9.8.dylib:_DH_free, *0x100742118 = 0x7FFF8A4E6D50 dyld: lazy forcedbind: tcltls.dylib:0x100742120 = libcrypto.0.9.8.dylib:_DH_new, *0x100742120 = 0x7FFF8A4E70D0 dyld: lazy forcedbind: tcltls.dylib:0x100742128 = libcrypto.1.1.dylib:_DH_set0_pqg, *0x100742128 = 0x114E7C52A dyld: lazy forcedbind: tcltls.dylib:0x100742130 = libcrypto.0.9.8.dylib:_ERR_clear_error, *0x100742130 = 0x7FFF8A52DB30 dyld: lazy forcedbind: tcltls.dylib:0x100742138 = libcrypto.0.9.8.dylib:_ERR_get_error, *0x100742138 = 0x7FFF8A52DB10 dyld: lazy forcedbind: tcltls.dylib:0x100742140 = libcrypto.0.9.8.dylib:_ERR_reason_error_string, *0x100742140 = 0x7FFF8A550810 dyld: lazy forcedbind: tcltls.dylib:0x100742148 = libcrypto.0.9.8.dylib:_EVP_PKEY_assign, *0x100742148 = 0x7FFF8A4BDBA0 dyld: lazy forcedbind: tcltls.dylib:0x100742150 = libcrypto.0.9.8.dylib:_EVP_PKEY_free, *0x100742150 = 0x7FFF8A4BDAD0 dyld: lazy forcedbind: tcltls.dylib:0x100742158 = libcrypto.0.9.8.dylib:_EVP_PKEY_new, *0x100742158 = 0x7FFF8A4BD410 dyld: lazy forcedbind: tcltls.dylib:0x100742160 = libcrypto.0.9.8.dylib:_EVP_md5, *0x100742160 = 0x7FFF8A4F6F50 dyld: lazy forcedbind: tcltls.dylib:0x100742168 = libcrypto.0.9.8.dylib:_EVP_sha1, *0x100742168 = 0x7FFF8A55B140 dyld: lazy forcedbind: tcltls.dylib:0x100742170 = libcrypto.1.1.dylib:_OPENSSL_init_crypto, *0x100742170 = 0x114F10356 dyld: lazy forcedbind: tcltls.dylib:0x100742178 = libssl.1.1.dylib:_OPENSSL_init_ssl, *0x100742178 = 0x114D244F9 dyld: lazy forcedbind: tcltls.dylib:0x100742180 = libcrypto.1.1.dylib:_OPENSSL_sk_num, *0x100742180 = 0x114F7B653 dyld: lazy forcedbind: tcltls.dylib:0x100742188 = libcrypto.1.1.dylib:_OPENSSL_sk_value, *0x100742188 = 0x114F7B67B

    Further up there are a lot more binding to libcrypto.1.1.dylib, so it's not as much 0.9.8 overall as this excerpt might suggest, but any amount of schizophrenic bindings is a crash waiting to happen.

    Now why are the bindings done in this crazy way? It turns out the standard LDFLAGS include -flat_namespace which literally means "don't pay attention to what library a symbol should be from, just grab the first symbol with the right name that comes along". Pretty much the source of these troubles, isn't it? Indeed, if removing that flag and the subsequent -undefined suppress from the LDFLAGS, tcltls still builds just fine, and the bindings now look sane:

    dyld: lazy forcedbind: tcltls.dylib:0x100642118 = libcrypto.1.1.dylib:_DH_free, *0x100642118 = 0x114F7C221 dyld: lazy forcedbind: tcltls.dylib:0x100642120 = libcrypto.1.1.dylib:_DH_new, *0x100642120 = 0x114F7BFD0 dyld: lazy forcedbind: tcltls.dylib:0x100642128 = libcrypto.1.1.dylib:_DH_set0_pqg, *0x100642128 = 0x114F7C52A dyld: lazy forcedbind: tcltls.dylib:0x100642130 = libcrypto.1.1.dylib:_ERR_clear_error, *0x100642130 = 0x114FE1ACE dyld: lazy forcedbind: tcltls.dylib:0x100642138 = libcrypto.1.1.dylib:_ERR_get_error, *0x100642138 = 0x114FE1BD4 dyld: lazy forcedbind: tcltls.dylib:0x100642140 = libcrypto.1.1.dylib:_ERR_reason_error_string, *0x100642140 = 0x114FE26A1 dyld: lazy forcedbind: tcltls.dylib:0x100642148 = libcrypto.1.1.dylib:_EVP_PKEY_assign, *0x100642148 = 0x11500686E dyld: lazy forcedbind: tcltls.dylib:0x100642150 = libcrypto.1.1.dylib:_EVP_PKEY_free, *0x100642150 = 0x115006DE8 dyld: lazy forcedbind: tcltls.dylib:0x100642158 = libcrypto.1.1.dylib:_EVP_PKEY_new, *0x100642158 = 0x115006002 dyld: lazy forcedbind: tcltls.dylib:0x100642160 = libcrypto.1.1.dylib:_EVP_md5, *0x100642160 = 0x115002E37 dyld: lazy forcedbind: tcltls.dylib:0x100642168 = libcrypto.1.1.dylib:_EVP_sha1, *0x100642168 = 0x11500353E dyld: lazy forcedbind: tcltls.dylib:0x100642170 = libcrypto.1.1.dylib:_OPENSSL_init_crypto, *0x100642170 = 0x115010356 dyld: lazy forcedbind: tcltls.dylib:0x100642178 = libssl.1.1.dylib:_OPENSSL_init_ssl, *0x100642178 = 0x114E244F9 dyld: lazy forcedbind: tcltls.dylib:0x100642180 = libcrypto.1.1.dylib:_OPENSSL_sk_num, *0x100642180 = 0x11507B653 dyld: lazy forcedbind: tcltls.dylib:0x100642188 = libcrypto.1.1.dylib:_OPENSSL_sk_value, *0x100642188 = 0x11507B67B

    Not a 0.9.8 in sight, and now I can have wish eval http::geturl https://www.tcl-lang.org/ without segfaulting. Promising, but maybe a proper fix should rather be in the Tcl build system, since that is what contributes the -flat_namespace. Time for another bug report, I suppose.

  2. Change login to "anonymous"
  3. Change mimetype to "text/x-fossil-plain"
  4. Change type to "Build Problem"
  5. Change username to "lars_h"